The Line that Separates Terrorism from Insurgency
Sometimes it seems the distinction between counter terrorism versus counter insurgency gets blurred. After all, if the war on terror is global, what’s the difference if it’s being fought over here, or over there? Indeed, the main issue distinguishing these efforts is where the enemy is operating. In terrorism, they are working within your environment. With insurgents, you are fighting them in theirs.
Timelines for withdrawal aside, the Petraeus COIN doctrine spells out neatly the strategies to win a battle that go well beyond firepower to political, diplomatic, psychological, economic and social concerns. A war of hearts, minds and pockets. Alas, with few exceptions, most counter insurgencies fail. Absent brutal broad strokes that decimate a population beyond the insurgents themselves (the U.S. versus native Americans, or vs. the Philippines at the turn of the 20th c), insurgency is a real challenge to counter. How many such campaigns can you count that have succeeded?














